Yes, many homeowners replace shakes with architectural asphalt, metal or composite shake-style products, though the roof deck and any old spaced boards need to be handled correctly first. Local roofers can explain which options suit the house. Call the number on this page to be connected with a local roofing contractor in Fox Island.

Is it time for a roofer?
A few split shakes after a storm are a small fix. Shakes that crumble when touched, a roof that feels spongy under the eaves, or stains on ceilings under the shake slope suggest the problem has moved past the surface and needs a professional opinion soon.
Wind and wet snow
Dry, brittle shakes break easily in fall windstorms, and heavy wet snow can crack them where they are already weakened. Storm damage on an older cedar roof often shows up as clusters of missing pieces on the windward side rather than one clean hole. Check the lower courses first.
Heavy tree cover in this part of Pierce County slows drying on wood roofs, and fallen needles tucked between shakes trap moisture that speeds decay.
Homes near the water here face steady wind-driven rain and salt air, which wear fasteners and flashing faster than shakes inland.
Useful local facts for Fox Island
Because Fox Island has no city government of its own, permit questions for a reroof go to Pierce County PPW.
Washington requires roofing contractors to register with the Department of Labor & Industries. L&I's Verify a Contractor tool shows a company's registration status before you sign anything.
Island homes like those in Fox Island face open-water wind and salt air, and a roofer's travel by ferry or bridge can affect scheduling, so ask about timing when you call.
Fall and winter windstorms are the main source of sudden roof damage around Puget Sound. Lifted tabs and loose ridge caps are worth a look after a blow.
With big firs and cedars close to many homes in Fox Island, falling limbs during windstorms are a real roof risk. Trimming overhanging branches helps.
Nearby, the same kind of help is available in University Place, Gig Harbor and Lakewood.
Why shake jobs are priced differently
Cedar is labor-heavy. Each piece is split, fitted and nailed by hand, and matching existing weathered shakes takes care. Material grade, thickness and treatment all change the total, so it helps to describe the roof as accurately as you can on the call. Photos help the conversation.
When a patch is reasonable
Replacing a handful of damaged shakes works when the rest of the slope is firm and the underlayment is intact. If new shakes would sit next to crumbling neighbors, a patch will not hold long, and the roofer may suggest replacing a larger section instead.
Safe steps before you call
Stay off the roof; wet cedar is extremely slippery. Look from the ground or with binoculars, check the attic with a flashlight, and set a bucket under any drip. Take clear photos of damaged shakes, stains and any fallen pieces to share with the roofer.
Cedar Shake Roofing questions in Fox Island
How long do cedar shakes last in this climate?
What are the alternatives to replacing with new cedar?
Do I need a permit to reroof a shake roof?
Can wet cedar be dangerous to walk on?
More roofing services in Fox Island
Cedar Shake Roofing nearby
Helpful guides
Sources
Last updated: